Extra Extra Pizza

Christopher Miller a month ago

My new favorite pizza place, and that's saying a lot with the pizza places in Buffalo. Great food, the space is so cute, great wine selection and the staff were absolutely fantastic. It's also a tip free restaurant paying their people a living wage. What's not to like. Just go, take out or sit down. You won't be disappointed.

Juno Hunter 3 months ago

Stopped in when my mom was in town on a random afternoon. Both of us are gluten free. The gluten free pizza was delicious, well made, and came quickly. The place was pretty empty when we went but the atmosphere is really cute and I love that they're worker owned.

Ray Barry 4 months ago

Last night Shannon and I had dinner at Extra Extra Pizza and it was outstanding. We sat at the bar and Bridget took care of us all night. She was amazing. Super friendly, knowledgeable, and honestly made the whole experience even better. She walked us through the menu, helped us pick beer and wine, and gave us great topping suggestions for our pizza. You could tell she really knows the food and enjoys what she does. One of the coolest things she told us was that many of the glasses and plates were thrifted over time, so almost everything is mismatched. Such a fun touch and it really adds to the character and vibe of the place. You can tell there’s a lot of personality and thought behind everything there. The pizza was incredible. Crispy edges, perfect crust, great flavor. One of those meals where you’re already planning your next visit before you leave. One thing we really respected is that they don’t accept tips. That says a lot about how they run their business and take care of their staff. Even without tipping, Bridget still delivered the kind of service that makes you want to come back again and again. Highly recommend. Great food, great atmosphere, and exceptional service

Sheila Mamon 6 months ago

Amazing pizza,if dining in- the decor is vintage and the vibe is very relaxed. We ordered the banana pepper and bread crumb pizza Sicilian Style and took #21 home.. Will definitely go back. This is the the first tip-free establishment I visited which was neat.

Corina Simba a year ago

The experience is always great, we've ordered here a dozen of times, we prefer to sit in so the pizza is extra fresh, I won't go to another pizza shop that's how good it is, the workers are so nice and notice so much! Bread on the house for a long wait, how nice and tentative is that, you can't go wrong. If your thinking about coming here. Do. It. Pepperoni pizza with banana peppers. 🤤🤤🤤